A Strange Fascination With Tragedy…

When I was in third grade, we learned about The Challenger explosion, which happened 25 years ago today and is the reason why I’m thinking about all of this. In some way, my nine year old mind managed to turn this lesson into a cause for concern, that perhaps something equally as tragic could happen to my beloved teacher or even to me someday when I became a teacher. I managed to convince myself that if I really paid attention and became totally fixated on in, I could somehow prevent further tragedy from happening.

When I got home from school, I told my parents all about what I’d learned. In turn, my dad told me about how he remembered watching it live in the kitchen at my grandmother’s house where we were living at the time (whether I was there with him or not is still unclear. I may have been at pre-school, but he thinks I was there). He was talking to my mom on the phone and told her that it had just blown up, and she didn’t believe him. I have a memory of being in my grandma’s kitchen, of my dad sitting there with the TV on. I can see the coiled phone cord stretched across the room. I just don’t know if that’s the same memory. It’s been driving me kind of crazy for 19 years.

Later, at CCD (religious education for Catholic kids), I remember sitting in the church basement hunched over my workbook. I should have been reading or doing something pertaining to religion, but this whole Challenger thing continued to weigh on my mind. So I did what any other really weird little kid would do: I raised my hand and when the teacher came over, I proceeded to tell her all about the Challenger explosion. She said that was nice, but that I should do my work. Then she walked away.

That seems to be the point where I developed this odd fascination with tragedy. Later that same year, my 3rd grade class learned about the Titanic and I reacted in a similar fashion. It wasn’t so much that I was concerned about preventing future ocean liner crashes as it was that I just felt this sense of urgency to learn as much as I could. To this day, if I see an article or a documentary or anything about the Titanic, I will sit down and read or watch with great interest. The exception to this is the James Cameron film. I saw that four times in 1998 and won’t be upset if I never see it (or hear the song) again.

As time goes on, these tragedies keep happening, and I keep compulsively reading and watching, even when I become annoyed with myself because I want news crews to leave these people alone, but I also really need to know what’s happening. When the massacre at Columbine happened, I was glued to the television. I pretended like it didn’t bother me, but it really did. It scared me. If something like that could happen there, it could surely happen here. I still remember sitting on the back patio with the TV on, trying to do my chemistry homework, but really just watching the public memorial service. By this point, if you didn’t already figure it out or if you don’t know me very well, you have probably started to work out that I’m a bit paranoid. And neurotic.


Columbine still really bothers me. In the summer of 2009, I read a really great nonfiction book by Dave Cullen called, simply, Columbine. Cullen had reported on the events in 1999 and continued to study them over the next ten years. What he discovered was that a lot of what we were told and led to believe wasn’t true at all. That familiar feeling came back to me: If this could happen to a teacher there, this could happen to me. When I was in college, we were often asked in our teacher prep courses what our greatest fears were about the teaching profession. Several of my classmates repeatedly said that school violence and incidents like the one at Columbine were their greatest fear. My thought was that if I knew everything I could possibly know, maybe I could recognize the signs before it was too late. These same feelings stirred up again when the Virginia Tech massacre happened in 2007.

(As an interesting aside, the school where I taught in Virginia gave us school violence presentations at the beginning of every school year, showing us how easy it was to conceal weapons. Yet in 2007, when I reported my concern over the fact that one of my students was bringing bullets to school, I was told that it was fine, that the student was “probably” not a threat. “He only has bullets,” they said. “It’s not like he has a gun.” I asked how long it would be until he brought the gun too. They said nothing in response and did nothing about the situation. How frustrating!)

Like most of the nation, I’m sure, I spent days consuming every detail that I possibly could about 9/11. The human story interested me more than anything, and ten years later, I am still completely fascinated by “where were you” stories and the way so many people shared a singular experience in so many different ways. I get annoyed with the History Channel because they’ve been playing the same documentaries and specials for years. They now cease to teach me anything new, but I really want to learn more. I don’t know what it is about the way my mind works, but I can’t shake this need to understand (anything — not just 9/11). Even when I think I do, I still want to know more.

With the exception of the Titanic, all of these things (and others that I haven’t mentioned) happened in my lifetime. This fascination with tragedy and devastation that I’ve developed (case in point: as I’m writing this, I’m listening to/watching the Al Jazeera English live stream of the protests in Egypt) seems to be continually giving way to an increased interest in history. This isn’t new, per se. After English, history was always my favorite subject in school. The problem is that I’m really picky about it. Certain things really interest me while others don’t in any way. Some didn’t use to capture my attention, but over time they’ve started to.

The whole JFK assassination had always interested me. I’d heard my dad talk about where he was, telling me about all the teachers crying at recess and how they got a day off school for the day of mourning. Sometimes I just wake up and that sense of urgency propels me to start reading immediately. That’s basically what happened two years ago with the JFK assassination, and then my interest in the controversy surrounding it became an interest in the whole family. Thankfully there is no shortage of information about the Kennedys.

My grandma always had this tendency to read pretty much everything and learn all of this “stuff” that really served no purpose but to entertain her and/or satisfy her love of learning. I’ve started to realize that I’m becoming my Gram more and more in this sense (and others). When I was in college, she gave me this old, tattered copy of Helter Skelter by Vincent Bugliosi, who was a lawyer involved in the Manson Family trials. That book scared the absolute crap out of me and gave me the creeps the entire time I read it.

And now, since 2005, I haven’t been able to stop reading about the Manson Family. Clearly this isn’t from a point of adoration, but more from a point of legitmate interest. What is it that makes people DO things like that?

Though I’ve never formally studied it (it would never fit into my schedule in high school or college), it seems that psychology is an underlying interest here, too.

Most recently, I started reading an American history book that I’d purchased over the summer. Then I, a graduate of Susquehanna University, located on the Susquehanna River, drove my family and a few of my friends nuts for two days by asking ALL of them, “Hey, did you know that the Susquehanna was once a major contendor for the seat of national government?” The “location on the Potomac” was ultimately chosen, obviously, but maybe Pennsylvania Ave. was named in an attempt to appease the disappointed Pennsylvanians of the time.

But I mean, really, did you know that?


7 thoughts on “A Strange Fascination With Tragedy…

  1. I just read your article about the fascination with tragedy. I had googled that tag line as I too, suffer the same bizarre fascination and often attempt to understand where it comes from, and if other people have the same off-beat interest. I can honestly say that I have yet to meet many people who can relate to this subject with the same complete understanding that you have for the subject. Your experiences and mine are very uncanny. I enjoyed reading your post. I found it interesting.

    • Thank you so much for reading and taking the time to comment! Always interesting to find people who are like-minded — I really don’t know anyone who finds fascination with tragedy, so it’s good to know I’m not the only one out there. :) I’m certain that there’s something psychological (and psychologically fascinating, really) at the root of it. I’d love to find a class called “The Psychology of Tragedy” and take it. Would be so interesting to see what it is that draws people like you and me to those events in such ways. Thanks again for stopping by!

  2. Wow! That was an uber fast response. I can honestly say I didn’t really think I’d be lucky enough to get one. I’m honored. I only had a few moments on the site and read one of your other post and can’t wait to read more as we seem to be a bit on the “kindred” side of thought. I must confess that it is quite refreshing. I also think it’s neat that you are from PA. I read your post about unemployment and having to be “back” here. I can so relate, as I have returned to and can’t wait to flee and am starved for intellectual friendships. It’s tough when your mind works outside of the box and your creative not to exhaust your pool of friends. Please feel free to give me a shout out anytime as I am always looking to expand my circle of interesting characters to my “club” of friends. And thanks for dropping me a response. It’s much appreciated. Have a great day and I’m looking forward to reading more of your post.

    • The honor is all mine, new friend! I think that when people take the time to read my blog and let me know they’ve been here, the very least I can do is let them know I appreciate it. If I find those kindred spirits, even better! (Although I must say that I wish we didn’t have the “stuck” part in common. Here’s to getting out sooner than later!) I look forward to speaking to you more often. Do you also have a blog?


  3. Thank you for writing this blog. I am also fascinated with tragic events and have always been. Now with social media, mine has been taken to a whole new level. My most recent inquiries led me to incidents such as the Dyatlov Pass Incident, the Hillsborough disaster, and the Rhode Island Station fire. There are actually a few television shows that cater to people like us:

    Mayday (aka Air Crash Investigation)
    Seconds From Disaster

    Now I don’t feel like such an aberration of society.

  4. This was a few years ago, so i would be surprised if you ever see this comment. But, I am EXACTLY the same way. I have spent the better part of this morning looking for answers as to why I feel the way I feel and I can’t find any which is distressing. But knowing there’s someone like me is nice! I have had various obsessions over my life, ranging from the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fires to the Holocaust to the AIDS crisis to the salem witch trials, or even more basic things, like certain songs i can’t stop listening to or memorizing the alphabet backwards and every single president in order. I’ve always hated these things about myself but it’s nice to know I’m not alone.

    • Not alone at all :)

      I don’t know you or how you feel about podcasts, but I have started listening to a podcast called “My Favorite Murder.” In the first episode, the two women who host basically admit their own neuroses and that they’re obsessed with learning about these tragedies, to some degree because it helps them to feel educated so that they hopefully never find themselves in similar situations. It’s true crime, but it’s also this.

      Thanks for reading, and I’m glad you liked the post!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.